Screen Protector vs AppleCare: Do You Need Both?

AppleCare (or AppleCare+) and a screen protector aren’t the same thing — they work best together.

What a Screen Protector Does

  • A screen protector helps prevent daily wear like scratches, scuffs, and small impacts. It keeps your display looking new and can reduce the chance of chips or cracks from minor drops. It’s simple, inexpensive protection you use every day.


What AppleCare Does

  • AppleCare is repair coverage. If your iPhone screen or device is damaged, AppleCare can lower your out-of-pocket repair cost (depending on your plan and fees). It’s peace of mind for bigger accidents — but it doesn’t prevent scratches or keep your screen looking perfect.


Why Using Both Makes Sense

  • Prevention + coverage: The protector helps avoid damage; AppleCare helps when damage happens anyway.

  • Better screen condition: Protectors help keep your screen clean and scratch-free, even if you have AppleCare.

  • Lower hassle: Fewer cracks and scratches means fewer repairs, less downtime, and better daily experience.

  • Resale value: A clean original screen helps trade-in value, regardless of AppleCare.


If you want the best protection, use a screen protector for everyday prevention and AppleCare for major accidents. They don’t conflict — they complement each other.


Cost of Screen Repair vs Cost of Protection

A cracked screen can cost hundreds of dollars to repair. A quality screen protector is usually a fraction of that—and helps prevent the scratches, scuffs, and small impacts that lead to expensive fixes.

Real Repair Cost Examples (By Brand)

Apple (iPhone) — Apple out-of-warranty repair estimates (USD)
Examples from iFixit’s summary of Apple’s shared out-of-warranty estimates (as of March 2026): 

  • iPhone 15 Pro Max: $379 

  • iPhone 15 Pro: $329 

  • iPhone 15: $279 

Samsung (Galaxy) — Samsung Canada out-of-warranty screen repair pricing (CAD) 

  • Galaxy S24 Ultra: $311 

  • Galaxy S24: $225 

  • Galaxy A54 5G: $225 

  • (Foldables can be much higher, e.g., Fold inner display pricing shown in the same list.) 

Typical Protection Cost (CAD)

Screen protectors range widely depending on brand/type (clear, privacy, etc.). Here are real examples in Canada:

  • Apple Store (Belkin UltraGlass 2): $49.95 

  • Amazon (Spigen) example: $23.99 

  • With us: $5.99-$29.99


Page: Touch & Face ID Compatibility

In most cases, a properly installed screen protector will not affect touch performance or Face ID. Modern protectors are designed to work with iPhone touchscreens and Face ID sensors.

Touch Sensitivity

  • A good protector should feel smooth and responsive. 

  • If touch feels less sensitive, it’s usually due to poor installation (dust, bubbles, lifted edges) or a protector that’s too thick / low quality. 

What to do if touch feels off:

  • Press down along the edges to ensure full adhesion. 

  • Remove bubbles and trapped dust if possible. 

  • Check your case—some cases can push the protector and cause lifting. 

  • iPhone tip: if you use gloves, enable Touch Accommodations (optional) and consider a thinner protector. 

Face ID 

Face ID uses the TrueDepth camera system at the top of the screen. A screen protector should not block it as long as:

  • The protector is properly aligned 

  • The area near the top sensors is clean 

  • There’s no thick dust line or lifted edge near the notch/Dynamic Island 

If Face ID stops working after installation:

  • Clean the top area gently with a microfiber cloth. 

  • Check for lifting or dust around the top cutout. 

  • Restart the phone and try Face ID again. 

  • If needed, remove and reinstall/replace the protector. 

Important Note (Privacy Protectors)

Privacy protectors can slightly change how the screen looks from angles. They typically still work with touch and Face ID, but alignment and cleanliness matter more.

Need Help?

If you notice touch issues, Face ID problems, or edge lifting, visit us for a quick check and a clean re-install.

Frequently asked questions
Does the iPhone "Ceramic Shield" already protect against everything?

No. While Ceramic Shield is designed to be highly shatter-resistant, it is still glass. Interestingly, glass that is more resistant to cracking is often softer and more prone to scratching. A screen protector acts as a sacrificial layer for these everyday abrasions.
Will it affect my touch sensitivity or Face ID?

High-quality tempered glass (usually 0.33mm thick) is designed to be virtually invisible to the sensors. As long as the protector is applied correctly without dust or air gaps, your touch responsiveness and Face ID will function exactly as they do on a naked screen.
Does it help with fingerprints and smudges?

Yes. Most premium protectors come with an oleophobic (oil-repellent) coating. This mimics the iPhone’s original feel, making it easier to wipe away fingerprints and preventing that "sticky" feeling during use.
Can a screen protector actually prevent a screen from cracking?

Yes. Tempered glass is designed to absorb and disperse the energy of an impact. If you drop your phone, the protector is meant to shatter instead of your iPhone’s actual display, saving you from a repair that can cost hundreds of dollars.
How much does shipping cost?

Free in Canada! $5 to North America.
When will I get my order?

We will work quickly to ship your order as soon as possible. Once your order has shipped, you will receive an email with further information. Delivery times vary depending on your location.
How do screen protectors help with resale value?

Micro-scratches from keys, coins, or even sand in your pocket can significantly lower a phone's trade-in or resale value. Keeping a protector on ensures that when you're ready to upgrade, the screen underneath is still in "Mint" condition.
Are there health benefits like blue light filtering?

Some specialized protectors include Blue Light Filters or Anti-Glare coatings. These can help reduce eye strain during long periods of use and improve visibility when using your phone outdoors in direct sunlight.
What is "9H Hardness" and why does it matter?

9H refers to the Pencil Hardness Scale. A 9H rating means the glass can resist scratches from almost anything except industrial-grade materials. This ensures that household items like keys or even a knife won't leave a mark on the protector.
Can I use a screen protector from an older iPhone model?

It depends on the specific model. For example, iPhone 13, 14, and 16e often share the same screen dimensions. However, using a protector from a different generation (like an iPhone 11 on an iPhone 15) usually won't work due to changes in the Dynamic Island, notch size, or bezel thickness.
Are screen protectors compatible with all cases?

Not always. "Edge-to-edge" protectors cover the entire glass but can be "pushed up" by bulky or rugged cases (like Otterbox), causing bubbles. If you use a heavy-duty case, look for "Case-Friendly" protectors that leave a tiny gap around the perimeter.
What's the difference between Glass and Plastic (TPU/PET) protectors?

Tempered Glass: Offers the best impact protection and feels like the original screen.

  • TPU (Plastic): Thinner and "self-healing" for light scratches, but offers very little protection against cracks from drops.

Newly Arrived in the 6!

Pick up a phone screen protector today! Get it installed in minutes today, with a 30 day guarantee you are satisfied. Otherwise, we'll fully refund you back to your back in 24-48 hours.

Shop now